State lawmakers haven’t seen a price tag for drug testing welfare recipients in West Virginia, but both Republican and Democratic state senators are backing the proposal.
The Senate Health and Human Resources Committee advanced legislation (SB 6) Tuesday that would mandate drug testing for about 2,000 adults who receive welfare benefits through the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families program in West Virginia.
“It’s a way to reach people who need help,” said Sen. Ryan Ferns, R-Ohio, who heads the health committee. “It’s a compassionate approach. A lot of times they don’t seek help on their own.”
The state Department of Health and Human Resources has yet to present a cost estimate for operating the statewide drug-testing program.
Sen. Corey Palumbo, D-Kanawha, said he had reservations about the bill, but he voted to support it after state health officials told lawmakers Tuesday that West Virginia has an adequate number of drug treatment facilities and job skills program to accommodate welfare recipients who fail drug tests.
State officials estimate the drug-testing program could flag about 390 people the first year.
“When this has been done in other states, the results and benefits have been kind of questionable,” Palumbo said. “But when they [DHHR officials] say this is well within their ability to handle it, it gives you comfort.”
At legislative interim meetings last year, lawmakers learned that few welfare recipients are testing positive for drugs in the dozen or so states that already have the high-cost screening programs.
In December 2014, a federal appeals court upheld a ruling that Florida’s drug-testing law was unconstitutional. Florida’s program required testing of all public assistance applicants.
Under West Virginia’s bill, DHHR must have “reasonable suspicion” that a welfare recipient is using drugs before the agency could order a drug test.
“There certainly have been a lot of states that haven’t been successful, and we’re trying to learn from their mistakes,” Ferns said.
Any of three factors would trigger a drug test:
n An applicant shows “qualities indicative of substance abuse.”
n A person applying for benefits has a drug-related conviction within the past five years.
n The welfare recipient has a baby who tests positive for controlled substances within five days after birth.
Under the bill, those who fail drug tests must complete a substance abuse treatment program and a job skills class. A second failed test would prompt a one-year suspension from receiving welfare benefits. A third positive test leads to a lifetime ban.
“We have a drug epidemic in West Virginia, and anyway we can identify individuals who need assistance and point them in a direction to get assistance is something I’ll support,” said Sen. Chris Walters, R-Putnam.
Sen. Bill Laird, D-Fayette, was the only health committee member who voted against the bill. Laird is not seeking re-election.
The legislation next moves to the Senate Finance Committee.
Reach Eric Eyre at ericeyre@wvgazettemail.com, 304-348-4869 or follow @ericeyre on Twitter.